Comparison Of Book And Movie
& # 8220 ; One Flew Over The Cuckoo & # 8217 ; s Nest & # 8221 ; Essay, Research Paper
Comparison of Book and Movie & # 8220 ; One Flew Over the Cuckoo & # 8217 ; s Nest & # 8221 ;
One Flew over the Cuckoo & # 8217 ; s Nest is a book written by Ken Kesey to
carry through a certain temper within it & # 8217 ; s chapters. The feelings and tempers given in
the book differ greatly from those in the film because of multiple alterations in
character development. Each and every clip a film is produced from a book, the
manufacturers are forced to alter parts of the narrative in order to accommodate the audiences
demands for a faster paced secret plan. It is impossible to capture every temper or
puting which the writer creates. What is lost can sometimes be the existent
intending behind the narrative.
The word picture of head Bromden is a good illustration of the alterations
made from book to film. His yesteryear is a critical piece of information contributing
to the temper and apprehension of the narrative. In the film, Bromden is nil
more than a brainsick Indian who doesn & # 8217 ; t want to speak so pretends to be deaf and
dumb. Much of the apprehension and regard is lost in the passage between
book and film. In the book, Bromden has flashbacks to his childhood, illuming
on important points in his childhood. His background is ne’er even brushed
upon in the film. Of class it would hold been about impossible to state of
Bromdens life in a film, much less show the universe from his point of position as in
the book. Bromden is still a really interesting character but the existent mystifier to
his jobs is lost.
McMurphy is a really sly, cunning adult male. He knows how to play his game and
does it good. In the book as McMurphy progresses, he goes through many phases
where he is rebellious, so docile, so rebellious once more. This is due to the
fact that he learns precisely what it means to be committed and what it takes to
be released. Then he begins to see that all his ward mates ( I don & # 8217 ; t cognize what
you want to name them ) are numbering on him so he becomes re
bellious once more.
These reactions to his environments promote McMurphy to be non brainsick but
intelligent and quick. This is precisely the manner a character such as McMurphy
should move. In the film, McMurphy is non merely wild but rude. He tried to
ne’er be straight-out rude in the book ( more aggravating for the nurse ) yet in the
film he was. He ne’er stopped being wild in the film, taking you to believe
that possibly in fact he is brainsick. Mcmurphy & # 8217 ; s true character was lost in the
authorship of the screen drama, his intelligence and craft is lowered greatly by
alterations made by the screen authors.
Ms. Ratched is a powerful adult female in both the book and the film. She
knows how to play with peoples heads and manipulate groups. She keeps a tight
clasp on the ward utilizing elusive methods which can non be ignored to acquire what she
wants. In the book Ms. Ratched is the most powerful adult female in the infirmary, what
she says goes. In the film nevertheless, she non merely doesn & # 8217 ; Ts have complete control
but it seems as though the physician thinks himself as holding authorization over her.
In the book she has the ability to acquire him replaced at any clip and he knows
this. This is reflected in his willingness to obey her and his deficiency of new
thoughts. The film was likely changed merely so they wouldn & # 8217 ; Ts have to travel into
item about why and how the nurse was all powerful in the infirmary Her deficiency of
power was shown most greatly during the staff meeting when she didn & # 8217 ; t take it
and even had suggestions about her class of action made by other physicians. This
gave the nurse a less daunting personality.
The character development in the book and film differed greatly. Each
depicted characters otherwise and hence set a different scene and temper to
the narrative. While each character is fundamentally the same, elusive alterations in their
personality, topographic point in society and background lead the viewer/reader to see each
character from a different position.