Immigration Essay Research Paper 2
Immigration Essay, Research Paper
& # 65279 ; Immigration is amoung the most compelling issues with which we as a state are faced.
The overpowering sum of human smuggling has set focal point on the in-migration Torahs in
Canada. Canadian in-migration Torahs have been under fire by many protest groups who feel the
Torahs are both racialist and male chauvinist. The issues environing the work in which immigrant adult females are
restricted to has become rather a subject of statement. Historically in-migration Torahs were
highly racialist and male chauvinist orientated. It is claimed that the current in-migration jurisprudence is both non-
biased and just, nevertheless there are many immigrants and Canadian citizens that would strongly
disagree. The media itself plays a immense function in how people form their positions sing
in-migration. Many are confident that in-migration promotes economic growing and maintain
Canada internationally competitory. However, there are others who express concern about the
impact in which in-migration and citizenship policies are holding upon the values and traditions
that form the foundation of Canadian society.
Immigration Torahs have become a really important issue in Canadian society today. There
is much contention over the procedure in which immigrants must undergo before being granted
Canadian citizenship. The increasing demands for skilled workers, instruction entry degree,
linguistic communication demands etc. , are being seen as racialist proposals for those who are seeking to come in
the state. There are three basic classs immigrants can fall under ; ( 1 ) Independent –
selected for their economic part, including skilled workers and concern immigrants. ( 2 )
Refugees & # 8211 ; includes Convention refugees and other displaced individuals resettled from abroad, with
authorities aid or private sponsorship, and individuals who have successfully claimed
Convention refugee position in Canada. ( 3 ) Family & # 8211 ; close household members sponsored by a
Canadian citizen or occupant, including partners, groom-to-bes, dependent kids, parents and
grandparents. Immigrants must run into the choice standards for the class in which they are
using. They must besides undergo extended medical scrutinies and background cheques.
Admission may be refused to individuals whose medical status represents a danger to public
wellness or inordinate demand on wellness or societal services, who have a condemnable background, or
who are considered a security hazard. ?
Canada is plagued by a history of racialist in-migration Torahs and policies. For decennaries
Canadian in-migration jurisprudence was influenced by a racialist, inspired? White Canada? policy. It was
non until the 1960 & # 8217 ; s with the execution of the points system that this policy was eliminated.
However a closer scrutiny reveals that this racism and cultural selectivity have non
disappeared. Endeavoring to continue the British character of Canada, governments directed their
attempts towards excepting certain people from entry, while promoting others to settle. The
Federal authorities decided in the early 1900 & # 8217 ; s to take action against Asiatic in-migration and
devised different methods for detering in-migration from China, Japan and India. Prime
Minister John A. Macdonald commented in the late 1800 & # 8217 ; s that a Chinese individual? was a
sojourner in a unusual land..and he has no common involvement with us, he gives us his labor and is
paid for it and is valuable, the same as a threshing machine or any other agricultural implement
which we may borrow from the United States, or hire and return to its owner. ? In order to
understand the racialist deductions associated with the in-migration jurisprudence of today we must first
understand how far it has come. In the early to mid 1900 & # 8217 ; s Orient immigrants or in fact any
immigrant that was non white was seen more of as a ownership and beginning of labor instead than
a citizen. However, today? s Torahs are still prejudiced. The Federal authoritiess in-migration
proposal, privileges English-speaking, educated elites who are rich plenty to afford
in-migration. At the same clip it denies those who are non fortunate plenty to larn the English
linguistic communication in their state of beginning. There is besides the demand of at least grade 12 instruction.
In many states, basic schooling merely goes to rate 10 or 11, once more a rejection that many of
these immigrants have no control over. Refugees are being treated as condemnable from the minute
they are granted citizenship. Many argue that these refugees should non be forced to give
fingerprints and other demands that are associated with felons and condemnable behaviour.
Another statement against the federal in-migration jurisprudence is that refugee claimants should be
assessed, non by an employee of or a member of the Federal authorities, but by an impartial
group of legal representatives.
During a clip in Canadian history when citizenship rights have been by and large bettering
for adult females, conditions have significantly deteriorated for domestic workers. The state of affairs for
immigrant adult females seeking citizenship in Canada has gotten worse. The conditions of domestic
work, particularly live-in service, were so unfavourable that Canadian-born propertyless adult females
refused to accept the occupations. The belief that adult females are dependent on their hubbies has become
a immense restraint on many adult females. Out of the three in-migration classs, adult females are must
probably to fall under the household category because of this belief of addiction on their hubbies.
Many adult females wear? Ts have entree to several of these demands in their states, hence
neglecting to run into the demand. Foreign-trained adult females physicians and applied scientists are working here as
baby-sitters and mill workers to pay the measures. York Professor Valerie Preston is working on a
undertaking analyzing the experiences of 24 adult females from Hong Kong and China life in Toronto.
If they aren? T working they have kids to take attention of, ? she said. ? They could non happen a manner
to pay for twenty-four hours attention at hours that they needed to either attend linguistic communication categories or to go to the
professional training. ? Her findings show that these adult females are willing to retrain but merely
can non afford to
. Many hence choose to take occupations outside of their professions because of this
long making procedures. The chief business in which adult females are allowed to come in Canada
is domestic labor. Since 1983, domestic workers can merely use for impermanent work licenses.
After this period is up, these adult females are so allowed to use for in-migration position, but probably
will be returned to their state of beginning. Many people argue that portion of the in-migration jurisprudence is
both racialist and male chauvinist. The basic rights and freedoms of these adult females are being rejected by the
Canadian authorities. Immigrant adult females are needed more than of all time to make full these domestic occupations,
nevertheless, the standards for really acquiring one of these occupations has been on the rise. The point system
assigned domestic workers low points for occupational accomplishment, occupational preparation and
experience, even if they had old ages of practical preparation and experience in the field. As a consequence,
most domestic workers could non run into the demands of the points system to come to Canada
as independent citizens. Therefore most domestic workers that came to Canada came as
impermanent workers. Women domestic workers have been forced to populate with their employers,
and at the same clip wage into authorities revenue enhancements such as the Canadian pension program and
unemployment insurance, which they are non permitted to roll up. Between 1973 and 1979
domestic workers paid every bit much as 11 million dollars in revenue enhancements without seeing any return. Several
adult females groups have protested but merely little additions have been achieved. They have found it
highly hard to afford the clip and money to larn the English linguistic communication and develop new
accomplishments that would assist them go through the in-migration demands once their work license had
expired. Domestic workers have been denied basic freedoms that other workers enjoy in modern
society: the freedom to take and alter businesss, to alter employers, to hold their ain
topographic points to populate, and to bask personal lives outside work and off from the direct control and
supervising of employers.
The attitudes and sentiments in which Canadian Born people form about in-migration
comes chiefly from the media. Newspapers such as the Toronto Star, portray immigrants as
being felons. Equally many as 600 Chinese immigrants have landed off the shores of British
Columbia last summer. This human smuggling has received a one sided position in a great trade of
the media. An article in the Toronto Star clearly demonstrates that these immigrants are non
having any understanding from the media. The article writes:
The migrators came to North America seeking to do a luck. They were
neither flying persecution nor confronting any menace to their lives. What they are
happening out is that Canada doesn? T offer refuge to every alien who turns up
uninvited on its shores & # 8230 ; It is a shame the migrators trusted international felons
to convey them to the land they call Gold Mountain & # 8230 ; .And it is a shame that
Canadian taxpayers are passing 1000000s of dollars to maintain the migrators in
British Columbia gaols. ?
It is extremely unjust to take a position such as this without cognizing the exact state of affairss why each of
these immigrants came to Canada. It is highly biased to presume the lone ground they came to
Canada was to do a luck, who is to state they weren? t confronting threaten fortunes in the
state in which they fled. It is believed that the migrators spent $ 40 000 ( US ) to be smuggled
into Canada. Many of these people likely spent all they had to these human runners, for a
warrant that they would go Canadian citizens. However the media would instead portray
these people as the felons alternatively of in many instances the victims. The point is non that these
immigrants should all be granted citizenship, merely that biased, racist decisions about these
peoples places should non be made without cognizing each persons personal state of affairs. The
media coverage environing the state of affairs with domestic workers has been minimum. The
fortunes around this issue have non been covered to the grade that it should. Many
peoples thoughts and feelings about in-migration come purely form media coverage. With small to
no media coverage on domestic workers it is really difficult for the populace to understand truly how
bad and unjust by Canadian criterions this is. The media may in fact be more concerned if it was
an upper category white male that was being exploited, instead than a female immigrant. If the media
would really give this state of affairs some positive coverage and demo the public how unjust it is,
so there is no uncertainty that this would assist to reshape the in-migration jurisprudence.
Immigration remains a compelling issue in Canada. Immigration Torahs will go on to
be questioned and challenged by those who feel the Torahs are racist, sexist and merely non just to
all persons. Hopefully the state of affairs environing immigrant adult females and more straight
domestic workers will be reformed in the close hereafter. The function of the media has a profound
consequence on peoples positions of in-migration. Peoples must look beyond what they read in the
newspaper or see on Television, and understand that the persons presenting these narratives might be
taking a colored point of position. One should seek to see both sides of the state of affairs before organizing
their ain sentiment. The determinations we made about in-migration in the yesteryear helped specify who we
are today. The determinations we make today will assist specify the state we live in tomorrow, and
go forth to future coevalss.
Brock, Deborah. Lecture notes. October 22, 1999.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada. ? Into the twenty-first century: a scheme for in-migration and
citizenship? . 1994.
Comack, Elizabeth erectile dysfunction. Locating Law: Race/Class/Gender Connections, Halifax: Fernwood
Francis drakes, Shellene. The Toronto Star, ? Immigrant adult females forsake callings? . October 15, 1999.
Girard, Daniel. The Toronto Star, ? Chinese migrators stay in gaol? . November 11, 1999
The Toronto Star, ? Panic over migrators was indefensible? . November 15, 1999